Missed opportunities for vaginal delivery among women with HIV in Europe
Missed opportunities among HIV-positive women to control viral replication during pregnancy and to have a vaginal delivery.
Aebi-Popp K, Mulcahy F, Glass TR, Rudin C, Martinez de Tejada B, Bertisch B, Fehr J, Grawe C, Scheibner K, Rickenbach M, Hoesli I, Thorne C; for the European Collaborative Study in EuroCoord and the Swiss Mother & Child HIV Cohort Study., J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2013 Jul 9. [Epub ahead of print]
Introduction: Most national guidelines for the prevention of mother-to-child transmission of HIV in Europe updated between 2001 and 2010 recommend vaginal deliveries for women with undetectable or very low viral load (VL). Our aim was to explore the impact of these new guidelines on the rates of vaginal deliveries among HIV-positive women in Europe.
Methods: In a pooled analysis of data on HIV-positive pregnant women enrolled in the Swiss Mother & Child HIV Cohort Study and the European Collaborative Study 2000 to 2010, deliveries were classified as occurring pre-or post-publication of national guidelines recommending vaginal delivery.
Results: Overall, 2 663 women with 3 013 deliveries were included from 10 countries; 28% women were diagnosed with HIV during pregnancy. Combination antiretroviral therapy was used in most pregnancies (2 020, 73%), starting during the first or second trimester in 78% and during the third trimester in 22%; in 25% pregnancies, the woman conceived on combination antiretroviral therapy. Overall, in 86% pregnancies, a VL < 400 copies per milliliter was achieved before delivery. The proportion of vaginal deliveries increased from 17% (414/2 377) before the change in guidelines to 52% (313/600) after; elective Caesarean section rates decreased from 65% to 27%. The proportion of women with undetectable VL having a Caesarean section was 55% after implementation of new guidelines. We observed a decrease of late preterm deliveries from 16% (377/2 354) before to 7% (42/599) after the change in guidelines (P < 0.001).
Conclusion: There are still missed opportunities for women with HIV to fully suppress their VL and to deliver vaginally in Europe.
Editor’s notes: In 1999, following a randomised controlled trial showing a lower risk of vertical HIV transmission among babies delivered by elective Caesarean section, pregnant women with HIV were advised to deliver by elective Caesarean section where this option was available to them. In the last decade, accumulating observational data suggested that women taking combination ART with suppressed viral load who delivered vaginally were at very low risk of vertical transmission. This led to revised guidelines allowing vaginal delivery for women with suppressed viral load on combination ART.
This analysis of European data (with largest numbers contributed by Italy, Belgium and Switzerland) shows the increasing number of women having vaginal deliveries over the last decade. However, a substantial proportion of women had unsuppressed viral load at the time of delivery, and some received no ART prior to delivery, suggesting the need to engage pregnant women with HIV in care earlier. In addition, the data suggest that more women who have suppressed viral load could safely undergo vaginal delivery. The proportion of infants acquiring HIV infection in the period after introduction of guidelines allowing vaginal delivery was 0.6%, which is lower than 1.6% prior to the guideline change but suggests that further efforts are required to ensure that all children in Europe are born HIV-free.