Scope for improvements to the UNAIDS model of Modes of Transmission
Can the UNAIDS modes of transmission model be improved?: a comparison of the original and revised model projections using data from a setting in West Africa.
Prudden HJ, Watts CH, Vickerman P, Bobrova N, Heise L, Ogungbemi MK, Momah A, Blanchard JF, Foss AM. AIDS. 2013 Aug 6. [Epub ahead of print]
Objective: The UNAIDS Modes of Transmission Model (MoT) is a user-friendly model, developed to predict the distribution of new HIV infections among different subgroups. The model has been used in 29 countries to guide interventions. However, there is the risk that the simplification inherent in the MoT produces misleading findings. Using input data from Nigeria, we compare projections from the MoT with those from a revised model that incorporates additional heterogeneity.
Methods: We revised the MoT to explicitly incorporate brothel and street-based sex-work, transactional sex, and HIV-discordant couples. Both models were parameterized using behavioural and epidemiological data from Cross River State, Nigeria. Model projections were compared, and the robustness of the revised model projections to different model assumptions, was investigated.
Results: The original MoT predicts 21% of new infections occur in most-at-risk-populations (MARPs), compared with 45% (40-75%, 95% Crl) once additional heterogeneity and updated parameterization is incorporated. Discordant couples, a subgroup previously not explicitly modelled, are predicted to contribute a third of new HIV infections. In addition, the new findings suggest that women engaging in transactional sex may be an important but previously less recognised risk group, with 16% of infections occurring in this subgroup.
Conclusion: The MoT is an accessible model that can inform intervention priorities. However, the current model may be potentially misleading, with our comparisons in Nigeria suggesting that the model lacks resolution, making it challenging for the user to correctly interpret the nature of the epidemic. Our findings highlight the need for a formal review of the MoT.
Editor’s notes: This innovative study modifies the UNAIDS Modes of Transmission (MoT) model, which is used to estimate the distribution of new HIV infections in different population subgroups, with the findings being used to prioritize interventions. The revised model incorporates subgroups to the original population groupings – for example, the category of “female sex workers” is further divided into “brothel based” and “non-brothel based” sex workers; and inclusion of “transactional sex” and discordant couples. The addition of new categories means that this revised model requires more data. The revised model changed the authors’ conclusions about the epidemic in the example setting of Cross River State, Nigeria, suggesting that the original MoT model may underestimate the importance of different vulnerable groups, including girls involved in transactional sex. Overall, the paper suggests a need to review the MoT model to assess whether further refinement would improve the reliability of the model projections. The HIV Modelling Consortium is currently working on a revision of the MoT model.