Articles tagged as "Human rights / ethics / law and intellectual property"

Research on intimate partner violence prevention - complex ethical issues

Ethical challenges of randomized violence intervention trials: examining the SHARE intervention in Rakai, Uganda.

Wagman JA, Paul A, Namatovu F, Ssekubugu R, Nalugoda F. Psychol Violence. 2016 Jul;6(3):442-451.

Objective: We identify complexities encountered, including unanticipated crossover between trial arms and inadequate 'standard of care' violence services, during a cluster randomized trial (CRT) of a community-level intimate partner violence (IPV) and HIV prevention intervention in Uganda.

Methods: Concepts in public health ethics - beneficence, social value of research, fairness, standard of care, and researcher responsibilities for post-trial benefits - are used to critically reflect on lessons learned and guide discussion on practical and ethical challenges of violence intervention CRTs.

Results: Existing ethical guidelines provide incomplete guidance for responding to unexpected crossover in CRTs providing IPV services. We struggled to balance duty of care with upholding trial integrity, and identifying and providing appropriate standard of care. While we ultimately offered short-term IPV services to controls, we faced additional challenges related to sustaining services beyond the 'short-term' and post-trial.

Conclusion: Studies evaluating community-level violence interventions, including those combined with HIV reduction strategies, are limited yet critical for developing evidence-based approaches for effectively preventing IPV. Although CRTs are a promising design, further guidance is needed to implement trials that avoid introducing tensions between validity of findings, researchers' responsibilities to protect participants, and equitable distribution of CRT benefits.

Abstract access

Editor’s notes: Data from 81 countries indicate that 30% of women aged 15 and above have experienced physical and/or sexual intimate partner violence in their lifetime. Settings with the highest intimate partner violence prevalence were found to be in sub-Saharan Africa, the region most affected by HIV.  Intimate partner violence is now widely accepted to be both a precursor to and sequelae of HIV infection. In response, a growing number of combination intimate partner violence and HIV prevention programmes have been implemented and systematically evaluated through randomised trials. The authors of this paper discuss some of the practical, ethical and safety challenges introduced by randomised trials on violence prevention, drawing on experience from a project in rural Uganda.

International guidelines have been established for the ethical conduct of biomedical research involving human subjects. The subject of violence against women and the method of randomised controlled trials are not easily resolved with these standard guidelines. In response, specialised recommendations for conducting safe and ethical population-based survey research on violence against women have been developed. These guidelines are an important development, but randomised trials to evaluate intimate partner violence prevention programmes face practical challenges in responding to common research ethics and safety considerations. These include: what to offer control communities in a trial investigating the optimal delivery approach for an activity likely to be effective in a setting with no standard of care. This needs to be done while maintaining the integrity of the study.

Drawing from their experience of the SHARE trial in the Rakai District in Uganda, the authors offer three reflections from lessons learned. (1) Ongoing need to formally update programmes that address multiple and overlapping vulnerabilities of individuals experiencing intimate partner violence and at risk of, or living with, HIV. (2) Cluster-randomised trials are a promising approach for programme evaluation but introduce numerous challenges with practical and ethical implications. (3) Given widespread underreporting of intimate partner violence, evaluation of violence programmes may have particularly high levels of unanticipated demand. The authors advocate for a framework of relevant considerations to be developed to guide researchers working on activities to reduce intimate partner violence. These guidelines should address potentially common challenges. They also encourage researchers to share field lessons arising from their studies in order to a) contribute to the development of this framework b) for revising and improving guidelines for the ethical conduct of intimate partner violence programmes in low resource settings.

Africa
Uganda
  • share
0 comments.

Condomless sex + viral suppression = ‘safe(r)’ sex? Challenging the laws that criminalise HIV transmission

HIV transmission law in the age of treatment-as-prevention.

Haire B, Kaldor J. J Med Ethics. 2015 Dec;41(12):982-6. doi: 10.1136/medethics-2014-102122. Epub 2015 Sep 29.

Evidence that treating people with HIV early in infection prevents transmission to sexual partners has reframed HIV prevention paradigms. The resulting emphasis on HIV testing as part of prevention strategies has rekindled the debate as to whether laws that criminalise HIV transmission are counterproductive to the human rights-based public health response. It also raises normative questions about what constitutes 'safe(r) sex' if a person with HIV has undetectable viral load, which has significant implications for sexual practice and health promotion. This paper discusses a recent high-profile Australian case where HIV transmission or exposure has been prosecuted, and considers how the interpretation of law in these instances impacts on HIV prevention paradigms. In addition, we consider the implications of an evolving medical understanding of HIV transmission, and particularly the ability to determine infectiousness through viral load tests, for laws that relate to HIV exposure (as distinct from transmission) offences. We conclude that defensible laws must relate to appreciable risk. Given the evidence that the transmissibility of HIV is reduced to negligible level where viral load is suppressed, this needs to be recognised in the framing, implementation and enforcement of the law. In addition, normative concepts of 'safe(r) sex' need to be expanded to include sex that is 'protected' by means of the positive person being virally suppressed. In jurisdictions where use of a condom has previously mitigated the duty of the person with HIV to disclose to a partner, this might logically also apply to sex that is 'protected' by undetectable viral load.

Abstract access

Editor’s notes: The changing landscape of HIV treatment challenges assumptions about the HIV epidemic based on past knowledge and understanding. The authors of this paper set out why laws that criminalise HIV transmission may now need to change. This change is required because of the impact of antiretroviral therapy on the viral load of someone living with HIV and taking their treatment regularly. As the authors note ‘it is no longer reasonable to classify condomless sex as ‘unsafe’ if the partner with HIV has an undetectable viral load’ (p. 985).  What the authors do not discuss is whether someone on antiretroviral therapy does indeed have a suppressed viral load.  Indeed, whether the person’s viral load suppression may change between the act for which they are prosecuted, and the time of the prosecution, is not discussed. The viral load of someone living with HIV on treatment may not stay suppressed if there is a break in adherence. That said, this paper does very effectively highlight how the evolution of the HIV epidemic affects many areas of life and institutions; including laws that may be slow to adapt and change.

Oceania
Australia, New Zealand
  • share
0 comments.

Violence experience of women living with HIV: a global study

Violence. Enough already: findings from a global participatory survey among women living with HIV.

Orza L, Bewley S, Chung C, Crone ET, Nagadya H, Vazquez M, Welbourn A. J Int AIDS Soc. 2015 Dec 1;18(6 Suppl 5):20285. doi: 10.7448/IAS.18.6.20285. eCollection 2015.

Introduction: Women living with HIV are vulnerable to gender-based violence (GBV) before and after diagnosis, in multiple settings. This study's aim was to explore how GBV is experienced by women living with HIV, how this affects women's sexual and reproductive health (SRH) and human rights (HR), and the implications for policymakers.

Methods: A community-based, participatory, user-led, mixed-methods study was conducted, with women living with HIV from key affected populations. Simple descriptive frequencies were used for quantitative data. Thematic coding of open qualitative responses was performed and validated with key respondents.

Results: In total, 945 women living with HIV from 94 countries participated in the study. Eighty-nine percent of 480 respondents to an optional section on GBV reported having experienced or feared violence, either before, since and/or because of their HIV diagnosis. GBV reporting was higher after HIV diagnosis (intimate partner, family/neighbours, community and health settings). Women described a complex and iterative relationship between GBV and HIV occurring throughout their lives, including breaches of confidentiality and lack of SRH choice in healthcare settings, forced/coerced treatments, HR abuses, moralistic and judgemental attitudes (including towards women from key populations), and fear of losing child custody. Respondents recommended healthcare practitioners and policymakers address stigma and discrimination, training, awareness-raising, and HR abuses in healthcare settings.

Conclusions: Respondents reported increased GBV with partners and in families, communities and healthcare settings after their HIV diagnosis and across the life-cycle. Measures of GBV must be sought and monitored, particularly within healthcare settings that should be safe. Respondents offered policymakers a comprehensive range of recommendations to achieve their SRH and HR goals. Global guidance documents and policies are more likely to succeed for the end-users if lived experiences are used.

Abstract  Full-text [free] access

Editor’s notes: Violence against women who are living with HIV is common globally. This paper reports on a study of 832 women living with HIV from 94 countries who participated in an online survey, recruited through a non-random snowball sampling model. The survey comprised quantitative and qualitative (free text) components. Participants included women who had ever or were currently using injection drugs (14%), who had ever or were currently selling sex (14%), and who had ever or were currently homeless (14%). Lifetime experience of violence among respondents was high (86%). Perpetrators included: intimate partner (59%), family member / neighbour (45%), community member (53%), health care workers (53%) and police, military, prison or detention services (17%). Findings suggest that violence is not a one off occurrence and cannot easily be packaged as a cause or a consequence of HIV. Instead violence occurs throughout women’s lives, takes multiple forms, and has a complex and iterative relationship with HIV.

The study population did not represent all women living with HIV, and was biased towards women with internet access who have an activist interest. Nonetheless, the study provides further evidence of the breadth and frequency of gender based violence experienced by women living with HIV. Key recommendations for policy makers include training of health care workers working in sexual and reproductive services to offer non-discriminatory services to women living with HIV and to effectively respond to disclosures of gender based violence (such as intimate partner violence) as part of the package of care.

Algeria, Angola, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Belgium, Belize, Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, Bolivia, Botswana, Burkina Faso, Burundi, Cambodia, Cameroon, Canada, Chile, China, Colombia, Costa Rica, Côte d'Ivoire, Czech Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Denmark, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Estonia, Ethiopia, France, Gabon, Germany, Ghana, Greece, Guatemala, Honduras, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Jamaica, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kyrgyzstan, Lesotho, Malawi, Mali, Mexico, Moldova, Morocco, Mozambique, Myanmar, Namibia, Nepal, Netherlands, New Zealand, Nicaragua, Nigeria, Norway, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Poland, Republic of the Congo, Romania, Russian Federation, Rwanda, Serbia, South Africa, Spain, Sri Lanka, Sudan, Swaziland, Switzerland, Tajikistan, Togo, Transdniestria, Turkey, Uganda, Ukraine, United Kingdom, United Republic of Tanzania, United States of America, Uruguay, Uzbekistan, Viet Nam, Zambia, Zimbabwe
  • share
0 comments.

Risks and experiences of transgender women in Lebanon

Forms of safety and their impact on health: an exploration of HIV/AIDS-related risk and resilience among trans women in Lebanon.

Kaplan RL, Wagner GJ, Nehme S, Aunon F, Khouri D, Mokhbat J. Health Care Women Int. 2015 Aug;36(8):917-35. doi: 10.1080/07399332.2014.896012. Epub 2014 Apr 9.

Using minority stress theory, the authors investigated risk behaviors of transgender women (trans women) in Lebanon. Using semistructured interviews, the authors explored six areas: relationships with family and friends; openness about gender and sexuality; experiences with stigma; sexual behavior; attitudes and behaviors regarding HIV testing; and perceived HIV-related norms among transgender peers. Participants voiced the importance of different forms of safety: social/emotional, physical, sexual, and financial. Strategies for obtaining safety were negotiated differently depending on social, behavioral, and structural factors in the environment. In this article, we provide study findings from the perspectives of trans women, their exposure to stigma, and the necessary navigation of environments characterized by transphobia

Abstract access                     

Editor’s notes: Transgender women have a high risk of HIV acquisition / transmission, due to experiences of stigma, discrimination and transphobia. However there is a dearth of studies on transgender women from North Africa or the Middle East.

Interviews with ten trans-women from Beirut were included in this qualitative study. The study findings highlight the extreme vulnerability of transgender women to stigma, discrimination, violence, mental ill-health, financial insecurity and HIV and STI risk. Social support and emotional security from family, friends, and the transgender community was frequently lacking. Mental ill-health (9/10) and suicide ideation / attempts was high (5/10). Stigma and discrimination by peers and teachers at school, and at the work-place were common. Many also reported verbal, physical and sexual abuse and violence in public spaces. Many participants were selling anal sex to reduce financial insecurity. Money was a key motivator for condom non-use. 

Programmes with transgender women should be multi-component to reflect the complexity of their needs. They should include HIV prevention, advocacy of laws to prevent discrimination, employment opportunities to enable economic independence, and treatment and support for mental ill-health.

Asia
Lebanon
  • share
0 comments.

Regressive laws on same sex relationships increases stigma and reduces health service use

The immediate effect of the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act on stigma, discrimination, and engagement on HIV prevention and treatment services in men who have sex with men in Nigeria: analysis of prospective data from the TRUST cohort.

Schwartz SR, Nowak RG, Orazulike I, Keshinro B, Ake J, Kennedy S, Njoku O, Blattner WA, Charurat ME, Baral SD, TRUST Study Group. Lancet HIV. 2015 Jul 1;2(7):e299-e306.

Background: In January, 2014, the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act was signed into law in Nigeria, further criminalising same-sex sexual relationships. We aimed to assess the immediate effect of this prohibition act on stigma, discrimination, and engagement in HIV prevention and treatment services in men who have sex with men (MSM) in Nigeria.

Methods: The TRUST cohort study uses respondent-driven sampling to assess the feasibility and effectiveness of engagement of MSM in HIV prevention and treatment services at a clinical site located with a community-based organisation trusted by the MSM community. TRUST is a prospective implementation research cohort of MSM (≥16 years) in Abuja, Nigeria. We compared HIV clinical outcomes and stigma, including fear and avoidance of health care, across baseline and quarterly visits before and after implementation of the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act. Outcomes assessed were measures of stigma and discrimination, loss to follow-up, antiretroviral therapy status, and viral load. We compared outcomes before and after the legislation with chi2 statistics, and estimated incident stigma-related events and loss to follow-up with Poisson regression.

Findings: Between March 19, 2013, and Aug 7, 2014, 707 MSM participated in baseline study procedures, contributing to 756 before legislation (prelaw) and 420 after legislation (postlaw) visits. Reported history of fear of seeking health care was significantly higher in postlaw visits than in prelaw visits (n=161 [38%] vs n=187 [25%]; p<0.0001), as was avoidance of health care (n=118 [28%] vs n=151 [20%]; p=0.001). In incidence analyses, of 192 MSM with follow-up data and no history of an event at baseline, reported fear of seeking health care was higher in the postlaw than the prelaw period (n=144; incidence rate ratio 2.57, 95% CI 1.29-5.10; p=0.007); loss to follow-up and incident healthcare avoidance were similar across periods. Of the 161 (89%) of 181 HIV-infected MSM with HIV viral loads available, those who had disclosed sexual behaviour with a health-care provider were more often virally suppressed at baseline than those with no previous disclosure (18 [29%] of 62 vs 13 [13%] of 99 men; p=0.013).

Interpretation: These analyses represent individual-level, quantitative, real-time prospective data for the health-related effects resulting from the enactment of legislation further criminalising same-sex practices. The negative effects of HIV treatment and care in MSM reinforce the unintended consequences of such legislation on global goals of HIV eradication. Strategies to reach MSM less likely to engage in HIV testing and care in highly stigmatised environments are needed to reduce time to HIV diagnosis and treatment.

Abstract access 

Editor’s notes: Despite the recent implementation of progressive laws on same-sex relationships and marriage in several settings, other countries – including Nigeria – have moved to criminalise same sex practises. As well as broader human rights concerns, there is the risk that policies that criminalise same-sex practices, or the community groups addressing the health-related needs of these populations, might restrict the coverage of HIV prevention, treatment and care programmes. However, despite these concerns, there is extremely limited quantitative evidence on the impact of such policies. In Nigeria, the Same-Sex Marriage Prohibition Act was passed in 2011, coming into law in 2014. Before this legislation, consensual sex between male same-sex couples was already prohibited. The new law further criminalised same sex practices, including prohibiting participation in organisations and service provision. This study opportunistically analysed data from an on-going prospective cohort study of gay men and other men who have sex with men in Abuja, which had started prior to the law’s implementation, and continued after its introduction. The study assessed the degree to which this legislation impacted on gay men and other men who have sex with men’s fear and health service use. Unsurprisingly, perhaps, the study illustrates that the law did impact negatively on gay men and other men who have sex with men – significantly increasing their fear of and avoidance of health services, as well as increasing their levels of harassment and experience of blackmail. Prior to the new legislation, levels were already high, with the new law seeming to exacerbate existing barriers and stigma. The findings are important, illustrating how regressive laws can increase the stigmatisation of already marginalised groups, and undermine the gay men and other men who have sex with men’s access to health associated services. Supportive policy environments, along with HIV programmes for marginalised populations, form an essential part of an effective HIV response.

Africa
Nigeria
  • share
0 comments.

Don’t ask, don’t tell: concealment as a stigma management strategy in India

'I am doing fine only because I have not told anyone': the necessity of concealment in the lives of people living with HIV in India.

George MS, Lambert H. Cult Health Sex. 2015 Feb 23:1-14. [Epub ahead of print]

In HIV prevention and care programmes, disclosure of status by HIV-positive individuals is generally encouraged to contain the infection and provide adequate support to the person concerned. Lack of disclosure is generally framed as a barrier to preventive behaviours and accessing support. The assumption that disclosure is beneficial is also reflected in studies that aim to identify determinants of disclosure and recommend individual-level measures to promote disclosure. However, in contexts where HIV infection is stigmatised and there is fear of rejection and discrimination among those living with HIV, concealment of status becomes a way to try and regain as much as possible the life that was disrupted by the discovery of HIV infection. In this study of HIV-positive women and children in India, concealment was considered essential by individuals and families of those living with HIV to re-establish and maintain their normal lives in an environment where stigma and discrimination were prevalent. This paper describes why women and care givers of children felt the need to conceal HIV status, the various ways in which people tried to do so and the implications for treatment of people living with HIV. We found that while women were generally willing to disclose their status to their husband or partner, they were very keen to conceal their status from all others, including family members. Parents and carers with an HIV-positive child were not willing to disclose this status to the child or to others. Understanding the different rationales for concealment would help policy makers and programme managers to develop more appropriate care management strategies and train care providers to assist clients in accessing care and support without disrupting their lives.

Abstract access 

Editor’s notes: This paper provides a powerful illustration of the persistence of stigma in the lives of many people living with HIV in India. Using data collected in 2012, the authors illustrate how prejudice and discrimination shape the lives of the women and children included in this study. While access to antiretroviral therapy (ART) provided a way for participants to regain and maintain what is described as ‘normal life’, that same treatment could result in unintended disclosure. Participants spoke of the fear of being seen carrying ART, since illustrations of the pills were widely available at clinics. They described the challenges of disclosing to their children as well as other relatives. Disclosure to wider social networks posed a reputational threat because of the association of HIV with moral laxity. All these are challenges that many people face in other settings too, providing further evidence of the persistence of HIV-associated stigma. The authors also illustrate the unintended consequences of well-meaning policies. One striking illustration came from a participant who was using a free travel pass, available to people living with HIV to collect their treatment. The pass included the word ‘AIDS’ and a ticket collector ridiculed the woman and her husband in front of other passengers because of this evidence of infection. The authors make the point that encouraging disclosure may overlook the importance of concealment as a way to cope with stigma. 

Asia
India
  • share
0 comments.

The impact of homophobia and criminalisation on MSM HIV vulnerability worldwide

Sexual stigma, criminalization, investment, and access to HIV services among men who have sex with men worldwide.

Arreola S, Santos GM, Beck J, Sundararaj M, Wilson PA, Hebert P, Makofane K, Do TD, Ayala G. AIDS Behav. 2015 Feb;19(2):227-34. doi: 10.1007/s10461-014-0869-x.

Globally, HIV disproportionately affects men who have sex with men (MSM). This study explored associations between access to HIV services and (1) individual-level perceived sexual stigma; (2) country-level criminalization of homosexuality; and (3) country-level investment in HIV services for MSM. 3340 MSM completed an online survey assessing access to HIV services. MSM from over 115 countries were categorized according to criminalization of homosexuality policy and investment in HIV services targeting MSM. Lower access to condoms, lubricants, and HIV testing were each associated with greater perceived sexual stigma, existence of homosexuality criminalization policies, and less investment in HIV services. Lower access to HIV treatment was associated with greater perceived sexual stigma and criminalization. Criminalization of homosexuality and low investment in HIV services were both associated with greater perceived sexual stigma. Efforts to prevent and treat HIV among MSM should be coupled with structural interventions to reduce stigma, overturn homosexuality criminalization policies, and increase investment in MSM-specific HIV services.

Abstract access 

Editor’s notes: Homosexuality is still illegal in 39% of the 193 UN recognised countries. This criminalisation likely increases HIV vulnerability among gay men and other men who have sex with men. In this study, 3340 gay men and other men who have sex with men from more than 115 countries completed an online survey about their perceptions of homophobia and their ease of accessing basic HIV prevention services. The authors conducted an ecological analysis to examine the relationship between the uptake of HIV services among gay men and other men who have sex with men. The authors looked at structural factors at the individual level which included their perceptions of homophobia within the society in which they live and at the country level including criminalising policies. More than 50% of respondents reported difficulty in accessing HIV services including condoms, lubricants, HIV testing services and antiretroviral therapy (ART). Perceived homophobia, criminalization of homosexual behaviour, and low country investment in HIV services were each associated with reduced access to condoms, lubricants, HIV testing services and ART. Improving access to HIV services for gay men and other men who have sex with men is urgently required as they carry a disproportionate burden of HIV in low and middle income countries. This study adds to a body of evidence which suggests that addressing structural barriers such as the criminalisation of homosexuality and sexual stigma (homophobia) will be necessary to reduce HIV vulnerability among gay men and other men who have sex with men, globally.

  • share
0 comments.

What happens to people living with HIV who inject drugs in prison?

Within-prison drug injection among HIV-infected Ukrainian prisoners: prevalence and correlates of an extremely high-risk behaviour.

Izenberg JM, Bachireddy C, Wickersham JA, Soule M, Kiriazova T, Dvoriak S, Altice FL. Int J Drug Policy. 2014 Sep;25(5):845-52. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2014.02.010. Epub 2014 Feb 28.

Background: In Ukraine, HIV-infection, injection drug use, and incarceration are syndemic; however, few services are available to incarcerated people who inject drugs (PWIDs). While data are limited internationally, within-prison drug injection (WP-DI) appears widespread and may pose significant challenges in countries like Ukraine, where PWIDs contribute heavily to HIV incidence. To date, WP-DI has not been specifically examined among HIV-infected prisoners, the only persons that can transmit HIV.

Methods: A convenience sample of 97 HIV-infected adults recently released from prison within 1-12 months was recruited in two major Ukrainian cities. Post-release surveys inquired about WP-DI and injection equipment sharing, as well as current and prior drug use and injection, mental health, and access to within-prison treatment for HIV and other comorbidities. Logistic regression identified independent correlates of WP-DI.

Results: Complete data for WP-DI were available for 95 (97.9%) respondents. Overall, 54 (56.8%) reported WP-DI, among whom 40 (74.1%) shared injecting equipment with a mean of 4.4 (range 0-30) other injectors per needle/syringe. Independent correlates of WP-DI were recruitment in Kyiv (AOR 7.46, p=0.003), male gender (AOR 22.07, p=0.006), and active pre-incarceration opioid use (AOR 8.66, p=0.005).

Conclusions: Among these recently released HIV-infected prisoners, WP-DI and injection equipment sharing were frequent and involved many injecting partners per needle/syringe. The overwhelming majority of respondents reporting WP-DI used opioids both before and after incarceration, suggesting that implementation of evidence-based harm reduction practices, such as opioid substitution therapy and/or needle/syringe exchange programmes within prison, is crucial to addressing continuing HIV transmission among PWIDs within prison settings. The positive correlation between Kyiv site and WP-DI suggests that additional structural interventions may be useful.

Abstract access 

Editor’s notes: This is a powerful article contributing to the evidence base on the vulnerability of the health of people living in prisons. It highlights a particularly vulnerable sub-population of people living in prisons who are HIV positive. The study uses an innovative approach in recruiting a sample of people living with HIV recently released from prison, reporting a history of injecting drug use (n=95) on the basis that outside of prison people will be able to talk more freely about their drug use. The rationale for this study is simple: to document the existence of HIV risk associated with injecting drug use among people living in prisons. It is important since Ukraine and other countries of the former Soviet Union, have underplayed the need for HIV programmes including needle syringe programmes by denying that injecting drug use takes place in prison. This provides empirical evidence that it does, and among HIV positive people living in prisons, so the risk of HIV transmission to people who inject is high. It provides further evidence for the urgent need for HIV programmes among people who inject drugs  in prison. This is of particular relevance in the context of Ukraine, which has one of the fastest growing HIV epidemics globally, with infection driven by injecting drug use. The punitive approach to drug use in Ukraine is well highlighted through the study, by the fact that 76% of the sample were in prison on a drug-related charge. This paper confirms that injecting or other injecting risk behaviours occurred in prison, as has been evidenced elsewhere, and the majority of the sample injected prior to incarceration. It also shows that there is a lack of HIV programmes in place, particularly considering half the sample was aware of their diagnosis prior to imprisonment and the remainder found out while in prison. The study also shows a high prevalence of TB or history of TB (69%) but low levels of treatment while in prison. These illustrate a clear disregard for the health of people living in prisons, which is a breach of human rights, as well as being a poor public health strategy. Unlike other countries in the region, Ukraine does provide opiate substitution therapy to people who inject drugs, as part of an HIV prevention and treatment strategy. This paper provides further evidence for the need to extend this package of programmes to prison populations

Europe
Ukraine
  • share
0 comments.

HIV prevention laws based on moralistic judgements of lawmakers may increase stigma

'The intention may not be cruel... but the impact may be': understanding legislators' motives and wider public attitudes to a draft HIV Bill in Malawi.

Stackpool-Moore, L. Sex Transm Infect. 2013. June 89 (4)

Objectives: The law in relation to HIV has prominence in the formation and regulation of moral norms in regard to human rights, and in regard to criminalisation, the policing of sexuality and intimate behaviours, and the production of stigma. The research focuses on the potential and impotence of the law to govern for, and enable, the human right to health in the context of HIV in Malawi.

Methods: This one-country qualitative case study (Malawi) action research involved data collection during a 6-month period (October 2010-March 2011). Datasets include interviews with law commissioners (n=10), opinion leaders (n=22), life story participants who were people living with and closely affected by HIV (n=20), reflections of the action research team (n=6), and a review of the proposed HIV and AIDS (Prevention and Management) Bill, legal and policy documents.

Results: The analysis of the perspectives of the law commissioners, who formed the Special Law Commission and drafted the Bill, revealed that stigma was consciously invoked to delineate social norms and guide governance of notions of personal responsibility. The analysis of the perspectives of the life story participants, whose lives would be most directly impacted if these provisions came into force, reveals the extent to which the stigma associating criminality and HIV is falling on fertile ground through its engagement and generation of internalised stigma; unearthing an uneasy link between stigma and the law in response to HIV in Malawi.

Discussion: The results indicated that the proposed HIV Bill in Malawi manifests a tension between intention and impact. By incorporating criminal sanctions as part of the proposed HIV Bill, the lawmakers actively seek to use stigma to shape social attitudes and attempt to guide normative behaviour.

Abstract access 

Editor’s notes: This paper presents research that examines the impact of criminal law in relation to HIV on stigma in Malawi. Through interviews with lawmakers and life story interviews with people living with and closely affected by HIV, the author examined how participants understand the proposed draft HIV and AIDS (Prevention and Management) Bill. The legal initiative for the bill, whilst based on principles of non-discrimination, includes provision to imprison a person who knows that he (sic) is HIV positive and does not refrain from an act which is likely to infect another person or who deliberately infects another person. Of great concern, the interviews revealed that whilst participants stated a support for non-discrimination of people living with HIV, many supported criminalisation of HIV transmission. The lawmakers were almost unanimously in favour of criminalising HIV transmission as a way to seek retribution and justice rather than for prevention of HIV transmission. The author noted that the lawmakers were particularly judgemental and moralistic about the issue. The people living with or affected by HIV were less certain and provided arguments for and against criminalisation, especially in relation to deliberate transmission of HIV where knowledge of status is not known. They were particularly worried that this law may dissuade people from testing. This paper provides an important understanding of the tension between political level intent to reduce stigma around HIV and the moralizing position taken by law- and policy makers. More worryingly, the author suggests that the perpetuation of stigma through such means as this law could be used to maintain or establish social control. 

Africa
Malawi
  • share
0 comments.

Despite high STI vulnerability among sex workers in Kigali, Rwanda, stigma remains a barrier to service use

Prevalence of sexually transmitted infections, genital symptoms and health-care seeking behaviour among HIV-negative female sex workers in Kigali, Rwanda

N J Veldhuijzen MDPhD, M van Steijn BSc, J Nyinawabega BSc, E Kestelyn MSc, M Uwineza BSc, J Vyankandondera MD and J H H M van de Wijgert PhD. Int J STD AIDS. 2013 Mar 20. [Epub ahead of print]

Timely diagnosis and treatment of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) is often hampered by the lack of symptoms, inadequate diagnostics and/or poor availability, accessibility and quality of treatment in resource-limited settings. Female sex workers (FSW) are highly vulnerable for HIV and key transmitters of STIs. Among FSW (n = 400) participating in a prospective HIV incidence study in Kigali, Rwanda, only 15% (17/116) of women with laboratory-diagnosed non-ulcerative STIs at baseline reported symptoms. Only 27% (20/74) of women self-reporting genital symptoms sought care at enrolment, and 39% (46/117) of women with self-reported genital symptoms during follow-up. During focus group discussions, FSW considered treatment-seeking and partner notification important. Shame and feeling disrespected by doctors or other health-care workers were identified as barriers to seeking health care. A comprehensive STI control programme targeting both symptomatic and asymptomatic FSW should be considered in this setting.

Abstract access

Editor’s notes: STI control is an important component of HIV prevention programmes and includes syndromic STI management, health education, condom promotion, and partner notification and treatment. Timely diagnosis and treatment of STIs is often hampered by the lack of symptoms, inadequate diagnostics and/or poor availability, accessibility and quality of treatment. Many women (and to a lesser extent men) are asymptomatic and not all symptomatic patients will seek care. Some may not recognize the symptoms, be unaware of the risks involved, delay seeking care or consult unqualified sources. Sex workers are vulnerable to STI and HIV infection. Women commonly are not aware of infection, making service access difficult. This cohort study shows that most sex workers in Rwanda with laboratory diagnosed STI infections do not have symptoms. Even women with symptoms were unlikely to seek treatment upon enrolment in the trial. Shame and anticipated stigma remained a barrier to women using services. This paper highlights the need to eliminate stigma and discrimination, alongside the ongoing importance of the provision of effective STI treatment services.  

Africa
Rwanda
  • share
0 comments.